
Hailey Bieber Was Asked to Pick Between Rare Beauty and SKIMS. The Internet Immediately Picked a Side
A DealBook question about which celebrity brand she would buy turned into an accidental rerun of pop culture’s most durable relationship subplot.
Hailey Bieber was handed a perfectly ordinary business question and the internet did what it does best: turned it into a relationship subplot with a designer wardrobe and a comment section.
During an appearance at The New York Times DealBook Summit in New York City, Hailey was asked which company she would buy if given the choice between Rare Beauty, Fenty, SKIMS and Kylie Cosmetics. She paused, said “Hard choice,” and chose SKIMS, Kim Kardashian’s shapewear and apparel brand.
On paper, it was a quick answer in a conversation about Hailey’s own brand, the darker side of social media and the business of being watched for a living. In the online imagination, however, the question had a very specific guest star: Selena Gomez.
A Business Question Walked Straight Into Pop-Culture History
The awkwardness was less about SKIMS winning a fictional shopping spree than about Rare Beauty being included in the first place. Hailey and Selena have spent years being placed in the same cultural frame because of Selena’s former relationship with Justin Bieber, who married Hailey in 2018 after his on-and-off relationship with Gomez ended.
Neither woman needs to mention the other for the internet to start arranging the furniture. A brand comparison, a red-carpet seating chart, a vague caption or a photograph from the same city can become another chapter in a story that both women have repeatedly been expected to carry, whether or not they are participating in it.
That is why the prompt struck commenters as loaded. It presented four major celebrity-backed companies, but viewers immediately focused on the one name that came with the most pre-existing emotional architecture. Fenty is Rihanna’s global beauty empire. Kylie Cosmetics is Kylie Jenner’s long-running makeup business. SKIMS is the Kardashian brand with enormous fashion and shapewear visibility. Rare Beauty is Gomez’s equally recognizable beauty label, known for its makeup and mental-health-focused messaging.
Put them in a multiple-choice question and the internet will still look for the hidden answer.
Hailey Chose Kim. The Comment Section Chose Chaos
After clips from the interview circulated, some users criticized the interviewer for bringing Rare Beauty into the question at all. One commenter called it an example of an unnecessary comparison, while another questioned why a journalist would put Hailey in the position of choosing her husband’s ex’s brand among other options.
That reaction is telling because the controversy is not really about corporate taste. It is about how quickly a celebrity interview can revive an old narrative through one carefully selected noun. The women involved can be discussing businesses, beauty or their own careers, and audiences may still be nudged back toward a relationship timeline from years ago.
Other commenters defended Hailey’s response and praised the way she handled the question. Some described her as graceful, smart and articulate, treating the pause and quick answer as evidence that she had navigated an uncomfortable setup without turning it into a spectacle.
That split is the entire Hailey-Selena discourse in miniature: one side sees a deliberate provocation, another sees an unfairly constructed question, and a third applauds Hailey for refusing to perform the drama everyone else has already written around her.
The Real Winner Was the Question
There is something almost comically efficient about the prompt. It managed to combine four of the biggest names in celebrity commerce while making the most combustible option feel impossible to ignore. Hailey did not need to criticize Rare Beauty, compare the brands or explain herself. The existence of the choice did the work.
That is the peculiar power of celebrity branding in 2026: these companies are not just products. They are extensions of friendships, marriages, rivalries, aesthetics and fan identities. SKIMS carries Kardashian-world polish and scale. Rare Beauty carries Gomez’s intimate, emotionally open public image. Fenty represents Rihanna’s category-changing cultural reach. Kylie Cosmetics remains tied to the influencer-to-founder pipeline that helped redefine modern celebrity business.
Asking which one she would buy was therefore never going to land like a neutral finance question, especially when Hailey’s own Rhode brand was part of a wider conversation about celebrity entrepreneurship. The answer may have been brief, but the context arrived preloaded.
And because this is the internet, a short clip is more powerful than a long explanation. Viewers do not need a full interview to build a narrative; they need a pause, a name and a choice that can be replayed until it starts to look like a message.
Old Story, New Packaging
Hailey and Gomez have both been pulled into public comparisons that far exceed anything either woman has said in this moment. Their occasional efforts to shut down speculation or project mutual respect have never fully prevented fans from treating every adjacent detail as a coded interaction. The fixation survives because it is structurally irresistible: two famous women, one famous man, two enormous beauty brands and an audience trained to inspect the smallest social signal.
Still, the most revealing part of this episode may be how little Hailey actually gave people. She did not name Selena, revisit the past or turn the choice into a pointed speech. She selected SKIMS and moved on to the next question.
The internet, naturally, did not. It took a few seconds at a business summit and dressed them up as a new installment of a saga that refuses to stay in the archive. Somewhere between the brand list and the comment section, a hypothetical purchase became celebrity diplomacy.
SKIMS got the hypothetical sale. Rare Beauty got the headline. And the interview question got exactly the kind of attention it seemed destined to attract.

Brielle Biermann’s Wedding Has a Very Complicated Guest List
As the reality-TV heiress prepares to marry Bill Seidl in Florida, her brother KJ’s attendance remains unclear—and her 12-year-old siblings reportedly won’t be there.
A Biermann wedding was never going to be a quiet little courthouse moment. But Brielle Biermann’s Florida nuptials now come with the kind of family drama that makes a seating chart feel like a legal document.
The 29-year-old reality-TV personality is set to marry minor league baseball player Bill Seidl this weekend, while the question of whether her 15-year-old brother, KJ Biermann, will be able to attend remains very much up in the air. Page Six reports that KJ is currently on house arrest in connection with an ongoing sexual assault case, and no court filing had been made requesting temporary permission for him to attend at the time of publication.
Meanwhile, Brielle’s 12-year-old half-siblings, twins Kaia and Kane, are reportedly not going. One source told Page Six simply: “Not going.” And just like that, a family wedding has acquired the atmosphere of a very tense group chat.
The guest list is suddenly the story
Brielle’s wedding should, in theory, be a glossy new chapter: Florida, a professional baseball player groom, and a family that has spent years turning milestone events into highly watchable television. Instead, attention has shifted toward who may be absent—and why.
Page Six reports that KJ is living with his mother, Kim Zolciak, while under house arrest after being granted a $200,000 bond in September. He has pleaded not guilty to seven felony charges stemming from an alleged April incident at a Life Time gym in Alpharetta, Georgia. The charges include aggravated child molestation, aggravated sexual battery, aggravated sodomy, sexual battery against a child under 16 and false imprisonment.
Those are allegations, not convictions. But the legal restrictions surrounding the case make a last-minute wedding appearance far from straightforward. A court would need to authorize any travel or exception to the conditions of KJ’s house arrest, and Page Six says no such request had been filed when it published its report.
That leaves Brielle’s big weekend with an unusually visible question hanging over it: Can the family gather without turning the ceremony into a legal and public-relations minefield?
A family already used to living in public
The Biermanns have been reality-TV famous long enough to understand that family milestones rarely stay private for long. Kim Zolciak and former NFL player Kroy Biermann built their blended household into a central storyline on Real Housewives of Atlanta and later Don’t Be Tardy, with Brielle and her siblings growing up in front of cameras, headlines and social media.
That history makes the wedding’s guest list feel less like a private family decision and more like a public-facing piece of the Biermann brand. Brielle has been sharing the runway toward marriage with Bill Seidl, while her family’s complicated circumstances have become part of the surrounding conversation whether anyone involved wanted that balance.
There is also a particularly strange contrast at work here. Weddings are supposed to be the ultimate family photo-op: everyone dressed up, everyone smiling, every emotional moment ready for Instagram. But this one may produce a very different kind of visual—a conspicuous absence, a missing sibling, or a guest list carefully arranged around a court order.
And with Kaia and Kane reportedly staying home, the absence is not limited to KJ. The twins are still children, and no reason for their nonattendance was given. Their reported decision not to attend adds another layer of uncertainty without turning their private circumstances into a spectacle.
The legal backdrop is getting heavier
The wedding news arrives as KJ’s case becomes more serious in the public record. In new court documents obtained by Page Six, Fulton County prosecutors referenced an earlier 2023 juvenile case involving 16 alleged offenses. Prosecutors are seeking to keep the current case out of juvenile court, arguing that KJ presents a risk to the community and that the allegations reflect a pattern of escalating behavior.
KJ has pleaded not guilty in the current case. His attorney is Brian Steel, who has previously represented high-profile clients including Sean “Diddy” Combs and Young Thug. Kim has publicly supported her son against the allegations, and KJ remains under the supervision of the court while the case proceeds.
That legal context matters because this is not simply a question of whether one relative feels awkward at a wedding. KJ’s movements are restricted, the prosecutors’ arguments are now part of a public filing, and the family is navigating a major celebration against the backdrop of an active felony case involving a minor.
It also explains why the wedding’s guest list is drawing so much attention. In a normal family situation, someone missing from a ceremony might prompt a few whispered questions. In the Biermann universe, the missing person can become the entire plot.
Brielle’s new chapter, under a very old spotlight
Brielle and Seidl’s wedding is still meant to be about the couple. The groom’s minor league baseball career and Brielle’s long public history have already given the relationship a built-in audience, but the family drama threatens to swallow the romance whole.
That is the uncomfortable trick of celebrity-family weddings: the couple may be celebrating a future together, while everyone else is watching the guest list for clues about the present. Who stands beside the bride? Who appears in the family photos? Who is noticeably missing from the dance floor? In this case, those questions are tied to court restrictions and child-safety concerns, not merely a sibling feud or a classic reality-TV falling-out.
For now, KJ’s appearance remains unresolved, and Kaia and Kane are reportedly out. Brielle will walk into her wedding weekend with the spotlight firmly attached—not just to her dress, her groom or the Florida setting, but to the complicated family orbit she has spent most of her life navigating in public.
Some brides get “something borrowed, something blue.” Brielle may be getting something much more 2026: a wedding guest list that doubles as breaking news.

Hailey Bieber’s Birthday Gift to Herself Is a Reversible Windbreaker and a New Way to Sell the Glazed-Doughnut Dream
For her 30th birthday, the Rhode founder is taking her signature shine into sporty territory with the brand’s first clothing item, matte blush and a cherry-cola lip balm.
Hailey Bieber is turning 30, and instead of quietly accepting flowers, cake and a suspiciously expensive candle, she has done what any modern beauty mogul with a signature aesthetic would do: she put her birthday on the internet and made it shoppable.
The new Rhode collection is a birthday-themed expansion of the world Bieber has been building around glossy lips, minimal makeup and the eternal promise of looking effortlessly hydrated. This time, though, the vibe is less bathroom counter and more off-duty athlete with excellent publicists. The collection arrives in navy, gray and burgundy, bringing Rhode’s familiar beauty language into a sportier, slightly more dressed-up mood.
The headline item is the HB Windbreaker, Rhode’s first-ever clothing design. It costs $148 and is reversible, with navy nylon on one side and gray fleece on the other. It is limited to one per customer, which gives the jacket the exact kind of controlled scarcity that turns a birthday drop into a small-scale online event. One side says retro track-club cool. The other says you might be heading to the airport, but you still expect someone to photograph you there.
Rhode is leaving the bathroom cabinet
Until now, Rhode’s universe has mostly lived in the compact, the tube and the lip case. The windbreaker changes the proportions. It is not just another branded sweatshirt or a logo-heavy merch exercise; it is the first time the brand is asking customers to wear the Rhode world on their shoulders.
That distinction matters because Bieber’s appeal has always been tied to a very specific kind of visual restraint. The look is pared back but not plain, polished but not overly formal, and casual in a way that clearly required planning. A reversible jacket in navy nylon and gray fleece fits neatly into that formula. It offers two moods without asking the wearer to become a different person: sporty on one side, soft on the other, always ready for a candid photo that may or may not be candid.
The color palette does some of the heavy lifting. Navy is less obvious than pink but just as easy to build a lifestyle around, and it gives the collection a cooler, more collegiate edge. Gray fleece makes the jacket feel tactile and wearable; navy nylon gives it the sharper, slightly technical finish that keeps it from drifting into basic loungewear. The result is birthday merch with ambitions beyond the gift bag.
The matte blush plot twist
The most interesting beauty move in the drop may be the Pocket Plush blushes. They are Rhode’s first matte blushes, a notable turn for a brand so closely associated with gleam, gloss and the “glazed donut” look.
There are two shades: Baldwin, a berry rose, and Tucson, a rich burgundy. Neither sounds like a timid introduction to matte makeup. These are moodier, deeper colors that suggest Rhode is interested in giving its famously dewy customer a little more structure without asking her to abandon the shine entirely.
That balance is the whole point of this collection. The matte blushes add contrast, but they do not cancel the glossy identity that made the brand recognizable. They are the velvet ribbon around the glass bottle, the slightly serious shoe with an otherwise soft outfit. Even the names feel more grown-up than sugary: Baldwin and Tucson belong to a collection that wants to look sporty, but not juvenile.
The Pocket Plush blushes cost $16 each, and they are also included in the $55 Birthday Set alongside both shades of blush and the special lip balm. It is a compact little package for anyone who wants the full birthday mood without committing to the jacket—or for anyone who has learned that a coordinated beauty set is more dangerous than a single product because it creates the illusion of restraint.
And yes, the lip gloss is still the main character
Bieber is not abandoning gloss just because she has discovered matte blush. The collection includes a cherry cola-scented version of Rhode’s Peptide Lip Boost, priced at $23. It provides hydration, plumping and a subtle pink-and-gold sheen, which is essentially the Rhode worldview translated into a flavor: shiny, softly tinted and just nostalgic enough to make the whole thing feel like a treat.
Cherry cola is a smart pivot from the clean, pale sweetness associated with the glazed-doughnut era. It is darker, warmer and a little more mischievous, but the finish keeps it from becoming a full departure. The shade does not appear to be staging a rebellion against Rhode’s core identity. It is more like the glossy girl has ordered something with a darker syrup.
The collection also includes Peptide Eye Prep Masks for $25, a $46 Snap-On Lip Case and a navy Carry Case priced at $38. The lip case is particularly on-brand: a small accessory that turns carrying a beauty product into part of the outfit. The Carry Case, meanwhile, gives the whole drop somewhere to live, because apparently the modern cosmetic routine now requires its own travel architecture.
A birthday drop with a wardrobe attached
There is something revealing about the order of operations here. Bieber is not launching a random clothing capsule and then sprinkling beauty products around it. She is extending a beauty identity into clothes and accessories, keeping the familiar details—navy, soft texture, shine, compact portability—intact as the category changes.
That makes the windbreaker feel less like a souvenir and more like a test of how far the Rhode aesthetic can travel. Can a brand built on lip treatments and skincare become something you wear outside the house? This drop’s answer is a confident yes, provided the jacket is reversible, the blush is perfectly named and the lip balm still catches the light.
For Bieber’s 30th birthday, the present is not one dramatic reinvention. It is a series of small adjustments: glossy becomes cherry cola, dewy gets paired with matte, beauty products get a carry case and the bathroom-counter uniform gets a navy outer layer. The effect is less “new era” than “same girl, better packing.”
Whether shoppers want the $148 windbreaker, the $16 Pocket Plush blushes or simply the birthday lip balm, the collection understands the assignment: make the everyday object feel like part of a very specific life. In Rhode’s world, even a fleece-lined jacket is apparently an invitation to look casually put together while carrying something tiny, shiny and limited-edition.